Elect Sam Toll For County Commissioner
Gilman v. Toll

Gilman v. Toll Nears Conclusion

Bottom of the 9th for Gilman v. Toll

On March 19th, Judge James Wilson issued an “Order After Remand” in the Gilman v. Toll defamation case. In his order (which you can find below this article), Wilson considers the case based on the Supreme Court decision issued on December 5th.

Supreme Court Approved Reporting

In their decision, Nevada’s Supreme Court ruled that I am a reporter because of the substance of the articles I publish. In his decision, Judge Wilson concludes “the Court finds and concludes Toll’s blog was the functional equivalent of a traditional printed newspaper and therefore is a newspaper.”

Thanks to this, Judge Wilson denied Gilman’s motion to compel me to endure further discovery and depositions. He also denied Gilman’s request to depose the three expert witnesses we offered in our response.

Finally, Wilson offered Gilman one last chance to prove his case on our special motion to dismiss. In a previous ruling, Judge Wilson stated that Gilman has not provided prima facia evidence to prove malice in my now (mildly) infamous residence communications article.

Gilman may file supplemental points and authorities to gleans any undiscovered nuggets in the deposition conducted nearly two years ago. We get to answer his brief and he gets to answer ours. The filings must be submitted up by May 3, 2020.

Bases Empty, Two Strikes

In closing, Wilson states “The special motion is ripe for decision.” Using an apt baseball analogy, Gilman is at the bottom of the 9th inning with the bases empty sitting on two strikes. He could hit a home run, but he has whiffed on almost every pitch served up by the case.

We expect a favorable decision in the weeks following the May 3rd deadline for filing. However, this is the legal system so anything is possible.

Stay tuned.



Elect Sam Toll For County Commissioner

About Sam Toll

Sam Toll is a native of Gold Hill and returned home in 2016 after 35 years in the Sacramento Valley. He enjoys old cars and loud music. And writing.

Check Also

Will Special Interests Control Storey County for the Next Four Years?

Special Interest Money Dominates Storey County Commissioner Races As the first weekend of early voting …


  1. This has been a very interesting case & the country is watching.

  2. David vs. Goliath. I applaud your perseverance!!!!!! Besides, I have my own take on Gilman….. (thumbs down)

If you have something to say, say it here!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: