Keep Free Speech Alive In Storey County
Gilman v. Toll

Court Dismisses Lance Gilman’s Defamation Suit Against Sam Toll

Victory For Sam Toll and The Storey Teller!

First District Judge James Wilson issued an order today in Lance Gilman’s defamation case against me (The Storey Teller founder Sam Toll). In his ruling, Judge Wilson granted my Anti-SLAPP* motion and ordered Storey County Commissioner and Mustang Ranch Brothel Owner Lance Gilman’s defamation complaint dismissed.

The case drew national attention from First Amendment and journalist advocacy groups who viewed my victory in the Nevada Supreme Court as a major step protecting the rights of journalists who report online.

In his decision, Judge Wilson wrote “There is no credible evidence that Toll published the resident communications with actual malice. The Court concludes Gilman has failed to show that his defamation claim against Toll has minimal merit. There is no credible evidence that Toll’s communications were not in good faith and in furtherance of the right to petition or the right to free speech in direct connection with an issue of public concern, and therefore it must be dismissed.”

In his order, Judge Wilson allows me to make an application to the court for reimbursement of reasonable attorney’s fees. Gilman has until June 29th to explain to the court why he should not pay me $10,000 in statutory damages as allowed by Nevada Revised Statute.

To the people who supported me throughout this ordeal in spirit and with their cash, I cannot thank you enough.

It’s Not Over Until It’s Over

Mr. Gilman is on the record saying he will appeal if he loses, so I know we’re not done.

However, I do feel as our nation must have felt on June 7th, 1944. While the war is not over today, the final outcome appears inevitable.

I will keep you apprised of new developments as they transpire.

Stay Tuned.

*SLAPP stands for Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation. This term refers to lawsuits that are usually frivolous and filed by wealthy people or agencies to silence public dissent.

In this case, it didn’t work.

Orrder Granting Anti-SLAPP MTD
Keep Free Speech Alive

About Sam Toll

Sam Toll is a native of Gold Hill and returned home in 2016 after 35 years in the Sacramento Valley. He enjoys old cars and loud music. And writing.

Check Also

Interview With Vanessa Stephens About Mail In Ballot Security

Storey County Clerk/Treasurer Vanessa Stephens explains the process of how her office will handle and count the mail in ballots.

17 comments

  1. All in all a very good day Sam, for you and the free press.

  2. WOO-HOO!

  3. It’s a good day! Congratulations Sam

  4. Way to go Sam! And thank you for standing up and defending the Free Press!

  5. Very good. Wish you luck the final outcome goes your way. Looks promising

  6. Great news Sam, so happy for you.

  7. VICTORY FOR PATRIOTISM!
    1. Sam DNA Dehne is very proud of you. But you
    already know that.
    2. The RGJ should be firing what they claim to be
    their govt watchdog (NOT!) reporters.
    3. And begging you to try to save Reno.
    4. Good luck in your quest for Storey Commissioner.
    Sam DNA Dehne
    PS
    In the meantime:
    “What could go wrong?”~Sam DNA [Feb 26, 2020]

  8. Congrats, Sam. Good job!

  9. Makes me proud !!

If you have something to say, say it here!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: